Give your loved ones a poke…Chocolate Mint Poke Cake, that is.

20130610-_LS_7703 web

Do you have childhood memories of Poke Cake?  I used to make Poke Cake for my kids when they were small, mostly because it was easy and they loved it.  Sometimes I made it with Jello, but mostly I made it with pudding and Cool Whip topping. My youngest (who just turned 20) does not ever remember me making a poke cake.  He only remembers cupcakes.

This is not a poke cake
This is not a poke cake

My youngest just celebrated his birthday at the beginning of this month and he requested that I make Poke Cake. I was glad to oblige, because Poke Cakes are much easier to make than cupcakes and Angel Food Cake (which I made for my oldest son’s birthday in May.)

I searched around the internet for some interesting recipes for Poke Cake and they had the typical Jello Poke Cake, Pudding Poke Cake, Oreo topped Poke Cakes…  Many of them looked quite interesting, but My Youngest wanted something with chocolate mint.  He has always loved mint, especially chocolate mint ice cream.  So, I found a recipe that he thought looked good with some adjustments to suit his particular idiosyncrasies.  He is my pickiest eater and so I need to be careful what I serve.  (His most peculiar dislike is fruit.  He will not eat any type of fruit and he’s not crazy about veggies, but he would rather eat veggies than any type of fruit…or nuts. )

Youngest with his girlfriend and Poke Cake
Youngest with his girlfriend and Poke Cake

In case you don’t know what Poke Cake is (I can’t imagine anyone not knowing, but just in case…) here are some examples: Jello Poke Cakes.  I’m pretty sure that Jello invented Poke Cakes, so I will give them creative credit here. You can find lots more creative Poke Cakes on Pinterest, etc.

Basically, Poke Cake uses a box cake mix.  We have always made our Poke Cakes in a single layer glass baking pan.  You can make them with regular two layer round cake pans, if you want to get fancy. Our family is a little more casual.  After you make the cake and let it cool a bit, you take the end of a wooden spoon (rounded end) and poke holes throughout the top of the cake…about 20-25.  Then you pour something delicious over the top of the cake,  like unset jello or pudding, making sure the holes are filled in.  Then, you cover it with a frosting, most often Cool Whip.

I’ve always used packaged cake mixes for Poke Cakes, because they are easy and they have a very light consistency, which is a good thing for soaking up anything you pour in the poked holes.  The recipe I used from Something Swanky Desserts and Designs called for pouring Sweetened Condensed Milk over the cake, which I did.  I might do it a little differently next time and use pudding instead of the condensed milk because the cake was quite sweet already with everything else that is added to it.

Here’s my adjusted recipe based on the above mentioned recipe.

Mrs. Y!C!’s Chocolate Mint Poke Cake with Andes chocolate Pieces

Serves 10-15


  • 1 chocolate cake mix + water, oil, eggs as listed on the box
  • 1 – 14.5 oz can sweetened condensed milk
  • 1 – 12.8 oz jar Hershey’s Special Hot Fudge Sauce
  • 1/2 – 10 oz package Fudge Mint or Thin Mint cookies, chopped
  • 1 – 16 oz container cool whip, refrigerated until soft
  • 1/2 teaspoon Mint Extract (or to taste)
  • 1 package Andes Mint and Chocolate Candies, chopped


  1. Prepare and bake the cake mix in a 9×13 baking dish. Allow to cool completely.
  2. Use the bottom of a wooden spoon to poke holes evenly across the entire cake (about 18-22 holes).
  3. Pour the can of sweetened condensed milk over the cake, filling the holes as much as possible.
  4. Heat the hot fudge sauce in a small bowl in the microwave for 30 seconds or so, just until it is soft.
  5. Place the chopped fudge mint cookies into the hot fudge sauce and mix.
  6. Spread the cookie/fudge sauce over the cake.
  7. In a large bowl, fold the Cool Whip and mint extract together.
  8. Spread the whipped topping over the fudge layer.
  9. Sprinkle the chopped Andes Candies over the top of the cake.
  10. Refrigerate  for at least 4 hours or overnight
  1. Poke the cake and fill with Sweetened Condensed Milk
    Poke the cake and fill with Sweetened Condensed Milk

    chocomint poke cake 2chocomint poke cake 1

Finished poke cake
Finished poke cake

It is better if it is allowed to chill overnight, so put that info in the hopper when you decide to make this cake.

The family birthday party for Pat was a success, except that the older brother had to work so he and his girlfriend could not come.  Pat’s sister (bride to be) brought her present in a pinata that looked like a gift.20130609-_LS_7523-Edit web Pat took the opportunity to use a large metal chopping key that one of his friends had made for him, to hack the present open, much to the surprise of his girlfriend, sister and almost-brother-in-law.  Aside from the Poke Cake, this was the highlight of his day.  Inside the present, he got some cute manly clothes and some silly string.

 20130609-_LS_7533-Edit web

Yes!Chef! made ribs, potatoes and corn on the cob.  It was quite delicious.

Then we served the cake.  It was chocolately and minty without being overpowering in either the chocolate or the mint.  The cake was moist, but not soggy.

Moist, chocolatey and delicious
Moist, chocolatey and delicious

The topping was slightly minty and the cookies and candy added a nice crunch.

Andes Candies Inspire this dessert
Andes Candies Inspire this dessert

You can see that you can be quite creative with a Poke Cake.  My family loved this one more than any others I have ever made.  And I must say, it was pretty delicious.

Chocolate Mint Poke Cake uses Andes Candies and Chocolate Mint Cookies
Chocolate Mint Poke Cake uses Andes Candies and Chocolate Mint Cookies
20130610-_LS_7693 web sq
You can see the chocolate under-layer here along with a little of the creamy condensed milk

20130610-_LS_7679 web

And most importantly, Pat loved the cake.

What else is there to say?

20130603-_LS_7266-Edit web

Happy Birthday, Pat, and many, many more.

Enjoy the cake!

Published by

Karen Schmautz


22 thoughts on “Give your loved ones a poke…Chocolate Mint Poke Cake, that is.

  1. I love mint! Actually on my very first post I used Andes in brownies! I have never made poke cake, but this looks and sounds so good — it’s on my list to try!

  2. Awwww… the photographs are so pretty.. Wow.. and I love poke cakes.. It always give you surprise in each bite and mint & chocolate.. Yumm.. I am going to try this recipe soon.. Thanks for sharing 🙂

    1. Oh, I hope you do try it. You could start a whole new trend in England. My ancestors came from Cornwall and Scotland some 4-5 generations ago, so I have a fondness for your part of the world. I hope to travel there some day and when I do, I’m hoping to see Poke Cake trending. 😉

      1. Ha ha! I’ll have to get busy then 🙂 Not sure I can create a cross-GB trend alone, maybe you should come over soon and help out??!!

  3. I have never had a poke cake, though I do remember reading of them in (I think?) a Jane & Michael Stern book. You make a convincing case, Karen! This certainly sounds better than the Jello ones I’ve heard of before.

    1. I really loved the jello ones that I made when my kids were small and they weren’t intimidated by them because they could see exactly what they were getting. However, I think Poke cakes make an excellent canvas for all kinds of creative ideas, besides jello…but they aren’t very pretty.

  4. I have never baked a poke cake! I think I’ve been just certain that I’d make a soggy mess. 🙂 I love having this recipe. If I am going to indulge in a rich dessert, I want chocolate. And this is a lot of chocolate. My kind of cake! I love to hear about a birthday party and all that represents in wonderful family time. 🙂

  5. Ive never had poke cakes but read about them quite a bit. Hopefully one day I can taste them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s